 |
Playing to Develop vs Playing to Win
National Teams Program Issue
ISSUE
In youth soccer circles today, an over
emphasis is being placed on winning. It
stems from social pressure in America
where we are expected to be the best in
everything. We glorify winning and first
place finishers. The emphasis in sports
on ‘winning’ is out of balance. Witness
the increase in violence at youth
athletic events. In sport, we are
obsessed with the ‘outcome’ rather than
the ‘process.’ As long as we win, we are
happy. We evaluate coaches only on their
win-loss record. What about enjoyment of
the process, the journey, the experience
and its ultimate influence on us as
people, coaches and athletes? What about
evaluating coaches on the improvement,
growth and development of their players?
After all, we can’t control the outcome,
but we can control the process.
RECOMMENDATIONS
Admit that we’re obsessed with winning.
When Suzie comes home after her game,
the first thing we ask is did she win
and the second thing is did she score a
goal? Reframe the way we look at sport.
Suzie, “how was the game today? Did you
have fun? Did your team play well? How
did you play? Did you do some of the new
things the coach asked you to try? Are
you hungry?”
In youth soccer, the priority for
coaches and players should be on
individual player development and
learning. Set age and ability specific
technical, tactical, psychological, and
physical goals to aid in optimizing
player development. This will provide
coaches a framework and structure to
follow. These goals also provide an
alternative for coaches and parents to
measure achievement and development of
their players. For under 14 and younger,
the primary objective of game
participation and training is to provide
the players with learning opportunities.
Teams should “strive to win,” but this
should not be the focus of any training
sessions, half-time talks or player
motivations.
At the age of 14 and above, careful
consideration needs to be placed on
balancing instances where in addition to
developing as individuals and a team,
finding ways to ‘win’ also becomes part
of the overall objective. One of the
biggest obstacles in women’s athletics
is that young girls are socialized not
to be competitive. By all means, ‘teach
players to compete, to compete hard, to
compete to win, but don’t have winning
be the only measure of success.’ Choose
which tournaments and games are to be
played to ‘learn,’ and which are to be
played to, ‘win.’ It is not development
to have a schedule where the sole
purpose for participation is in the best
interest of the players’ ‘winning.’
Individual and team improvement and peak
performance should be the measure of
achievement, rather than winning or
losing.

U6 Coaching Article
Attack the Play of 5 & 6 Year Olds…. Or
You Can Sit Back – Relax – and Have as
Much Fun as They Do!!!!!
By Mike Parsons
It’s good to know that some things never
change in life – like the play of 5 & 6
year olds on the soccer field. We can
all agonize over how to discover the
special training techniques that will
enable them to score more goals –
certainly those who have been in the
game for a long time must know the
secrets! Or we can stay up late at night
and draw diagram after diagram that
reveals in precise detail where every
player should be in relation to the ball
– that will solve the bunching up
problem and it will look like real
soccer! Or one might infiltrate the
marketing department at Mickey D’s to
figure out why the Happy Meal is more
important than the score! However, Mom
and Dad (especially Dad - he’s a winning
machine!), the game of soccer at 5 & 6
years old remains a game – with the
thrill of winning taking a back seat the
excitement of merely chasing the ball!
Anyone… and I mean anyone… can look at a
situation and tell you the problems.
Instead of that approach, I’m going to
make some suggestions for possible
solutions to some of the common problems
coaching the very young in
“chase-the-ball-no-matter-where-it-goes-until-I-need-a-break-and-then
do-it-again-‘til-the-game-ends” (that’s
what soccer for 5 & 6’s should be
called). Here we go;
Bunching Up Around the Ball. God forbid
that all of the kids chase the ball –
that would mean that every child would
be having FUN!! You see, that is what
every player at this age likes about the
game – they can run anywhere they like –
no adult is going to tell them to walk –
and they love the challenge of touching
the ball all by themselves! We tend to
forget that there is very little
organization in the mind of a 5-6 year
old and that sharing is not on the top
of the list of their favorite things to
do. (Do they share their favorite toys
with their brothers and sisters???)
Remember … It’s my ball !!!!!! Soooooo…..let
them chase the ball!! They will spread
out as they learn to play with their
teammates.
Scoring Goals … is an accident most of
the time at this age. Let’s be
honest-that clump of grass has more to
do with the direction that the ball
travels than the one who kicks it (at
this age shooting and passing are merely
“kicking”). However, scoring goals
should be the only thing on their mind
at this age. Remember this…we can all
focus on one thing at a time – focus the
young on scoring goals – that’s the
object of the game!
He/She is a Ball Hog…. Which brings us
to the question – Are Ball Hogs good or
bad? As a parent the answer is (like it
or not) bad if the neighbor’s
son/daughter won’t give the ball to our
little cherub – good if the ball is
always with our “talented little child
prodigy”. Wrong!!! This age is the
beginning of individuality – flair for
those who really want to exaggerate.
Encourage them to dribble the ball and
try to beat other players – my best
friend boldly told his son at six years
old…“ don’t pass the ball until you are
eleven – and don’t worry about the coach
when he screams at you to pass. His son
can’t dribble!”. In fact, all training
sessions at this age should be based
around each child and a ball. Acceptance
of failure (it’s OK not to succeed at
first …try again) and the encouragement
to try again will help the learning
process.
Practice Sessions...the longer the
better! What a great way to turn play
into work! Ever try to play golf every
day on your vacation – double rounds if
possible? It gets old fast. So why do we
keep 5-6 year olds at the practice field
for an hour or more during training? Mom
got some more shopping to do? Or is Dad
feeling a win coming on after 90 minutes
of practice? More is not better at this
or any age. Train them for the same
amount of time that the game will take
on Saturday. Thirty to forty minutes
will be long enough to wind them up
…then give them back to their parents to
calm them down. The excitement of the
soccer experience will then remain
fresh.
WINNING … it’s why we are here… Wow, I
hope we all have had childhood
experiences that were fun and not
necessarily based on winning. Everything
in life is based on winning… Do we
really want to emphasize the down side
of competition – losing - to 5-6 year
olds? They are not concerned (except for
that Happy Meal) what the end of the
game brings – so why should we? Remember
that youth sports were started so that
kids could have fun. So, bring a chair
and your favorite beverage to the next
game and save some room for a Happy Meal
of your own afterwards!
Work on the Fundamentals in Practice…
While other sports work on fundamentals
(and soccer’s numbers keep getting
larger) we have found that the most
important things to teach at this age
are motor skill development – the
ability to control my body – and an
appreciation for the fun aspects of the
game – me and the ball - look at what we
can do! We tend to forget that soccer is
not a hand-eye coordination activity
like all other sports in the U.S. In
addition the kids are presented with an
incredible challenge to make their
bodies do what they want them to (kind
of like Dad playing in the over forty
league in any sport – he gets it going,
you better get out of his way cuz’ no
one knows if he’ll be able to stop). As
a result, the objective becomes one of
making my body and the ball work
together as one.
Parental Support - The Key to Peak
Performance
The role that parents play in the life
of a soccer player has a tremendous
impact on their experience. With this in
mind, we have taken some time to write
down some helpful reminders for all of
us as we approach the upcoming season.
If you should have any questions about
these thoughts, please feel free to
discuss it with us, the coaches.
1. Let the coaches coach: Leave the
coaching to the coaches. This includes
motivating, psyching your child for
practice, after game critiquing, setting
goals, requiring additional training,
etc. You have entrusted the care of your
player to these coaches and they need to
be free to do their job. If a player has
too many coaches, it is confusing for
him and his performance usually
declines.
2. Support the program: Get involved.
Volunteer. Help out with fundraisers,
car-pool; anything to support the
program.
3. Be you child's best fan: Support your
child unconditionally. Do not withdraw
love when your child performs poorly.
Your child should never have to perform
to win your love.
4. Support and root for all players on
the team: Foster teamwork. Your child's
teammates are not the enemy. When they
are playing better than your child, your
child now has a wonderful opportunity to
learn.
5. Do not bribe or offer incentives:
Your job is not to motivate. Leave this
to the coaching staff. Bribes will
distract your child from properly
concentrating in practice and game
situations.
6. Encourage your child to talk with the
coaches: If your child is having
difficulties in practice or games, or
can't make a practice, etc., encourage
them to speak directly to the coaches.
This "responsibility taking" is a big
part of becoming a big-time player. By
handling the off-field tasks, your child
is claiming ownership of all aspects of
the game - preparation for as well as
playing the game.
7. Understand and display appropriate
game behavior: Remember, your child's
self esteem and game performance is at
stake. Be supportive, cheer, be
appropriate. To perform to the best of
his abilities, a player needs to focus
on the parts of the game that they can
control (his fitness, positioning,
decision making, skill, aggressiveness,
what the game is presenting them). If he
starts focusing on what he can not
control (the condition of the field, the
referee, the weather, the opponent, even
the outcome of the game at times), he
will not play up to his ability. If he
hears a lot of people telling him what
to do, or yelling at the referee, it
diverts his attention away from the task
at hand.
8. Monitor your child's stress level at
home: Keep an eye on the player to make
sure that they are handling stress
effectively from the various activities
in his life.
9. Monitor eating and sleeping habits:
Be sure your child is eating the proper
foods and getting adequate rest.
10. Help your child keep his priorities
straight: Help your child maintain a
focus on schoolwork, relationships and
the other things in life beside soccer.
Also, if your child has made a
commitment to soccer, help him fulfill
his obligation to the team.
11. Reality test: If your child has come
off the field when his team has lost,
but he has played his best, help him to
see this as a "win". Remind him that he
is to focus on "process" and not
"results". His fun and satisfaction
should be derived from "striving to
win". Conversely, he should be as
satisfied from success that occurs
despite inadequate preparation and
performance.
12. Keep soccer in its proper
perspective: Soccer should not be larger
than life for you. If your child's
performance produces strong emotions in
you, suppress them. Remember your
relationship will continue with your
children long after their competitive
soccer days are over. Keep your goals
and needs separate from your child's
experience.
13. Have fun: That is what we will be
trying to do! We will try to challenge
your child to reach past their "comfort
level" and improve themselves as a
player, and thus, a person. We will
attempt to do this in environments that
are fun, yet challenging. We look
forward to this process. We hope you do
to!
Mike Parsons is the former Director of
Coaching Education for the National
Soccer Coaches Association. He presently
directs W.I.N.S. Nationwide Education
and Consulting Services |
 |